Merin is a teacher, a book blogger, a baseball addict (Go Cardinals!), lover of music, movies and TV crime dramas, and YA/MG connoisseur. Follow me on my blog at http://ahandfulofconfetti.wordpress.com!
EDIT: Jessica Warman has written a little spin-off of this book that's posted on her blog. If you're curious about what happened to Richie post-Liz, check it out here.
Liz Valchar is one of those annoyingly beautiful, popular and perfect girls you meet in high school. However, on the eve of her eighteenth birthday, when she and her equally popular and good-looking friends are partying it up on her father's boat (which is named after her, of course), Liz is roused from her sleep by a thumping sound that irritates her so much she gets up to see what it is, and is completely shocked when she finds her own body face down in the water, dead. Soon after, she meets Alex, a schoolmate (but not a friend) who was killed the previous year in a mysterious hit-and-run accident, and the two of them set out to discover the truth behind Liz's death. How did she die? Who is responsible? Throughout it all, Liz must come to terms with the fact that she really wasn't as perfect as she wanted everyone to believe.
This book grabbed me from the get-go, especially once Liz sees her own body in the water. Liz is not a nice girl: there are several instances throughout this book where we get to see just how awful she really was. And then there's Alex, whom Liz doesn't like, mostly because he was a "nobody" in school: poor, nerdy, and a loner. I especially liked how he stood up to her in death (in a way he never could have in life) and made her realize exactly what type of person she was. I liked their growing relationship, as Liz had to come to terms with not only her death, but having to spend this "between" stage with someone she treated horribly in life. This was very much a coming of age book, in that Liz has a lot of growing up to do in order to figure out what exactly happened to her that night on the boat.
I do want to point out that Liz is suffering from anorexia in this book, though, and the scenes when she's talking about calorie intake or her nonstop need for control might be triggering for people who are suffering from the disease, so just a heads-up regarding that bit of the story. Also, it was really nice to see a stand-alone book! So much of what's released nowadays are series books that it was great to see a title that managed an entire plot arc in one volume.
There were lots of twists and turns in this story; I was constantly guessing about what had happened, and who was responsible, and why Liz died in the first place. The pacing and writing in this book were really first-rate; there was never a moment where things slowed down or lulled, but at the same time it wasn't non-stop, can't catch my breath action, either. Once I hit the midway point I simply didn't want to stop reading until everything was figured out. It was gripping and intense, and I enjoyed every bit of it.
Cora Alexander's life is forever changed when she falls into a sinkhole during her father's funeral and lands in the Underworld still alive. This, of course, upsets the balance of the Underworld and the rule of Minos and the judges, who control the realm with an iron fist and have turned it into a computer-generated world full of shades. With the help of her untrustworthy guide, Minotaur, Cora must journey through the realm to find a way to return to the world above.
That is the book in a nutshell, although I left a lot of stuff out (read the summary here on Goodreads if you want the full version). This book was strangely incomplete; there is no wrap-up of the story line and the book ends on what could be called a cliffhanger if I cared enough to be interested in the next installment. I felt like Cora is a very flat character; she does things, and occasionally provides a teeny bit of insight into why she's doing them, but we don't really get to know her very well at all. I also felt like the book suffered from too many points of view: there are at least three that I can remember off the top of my head, and switching between the points of view (one of which is strangely in third person while everything else is in first) caused the story to lose momentum and made it kind of tedious to read. After a fast-paced start which grabbed my attention, the rest of the story just failed in comparison and I found myself really uninterested in how things would end. For me personally, this just wasn't a very well-constructed story. And that hurts me a bit to say that, because the summary was really promising. But there just wasn't any resolution to the plot, and I can't enjoy something that didn't have a point.
Also, a note on the e-galley version of this, there were some weird sentence breaks that made the reading experience even more annoying because I had to keep deciphering what the sentences were supposed to say. Here's an example: His arrival was merely the realization of destiny was entirely different through our gates. a prophecy. Cora's before she slipped. This makes absolutely NO sense, and what's supposed to be written was this: His arrival was merely the realization of a prophecy. Cora's destiny was entirely different before she slipped through our gates. Now this was a fairly easy one to figure out, but there were others where it literally took me a good minute to put the words back into their proper order in order to read them, which just further pulled me out of the story. Hopefully all of those issues have been found and fixed in the final version.
All in all this was a disappointing read for me. The characters were flat, there were too many points of view, and absolutely no resolution to the plot. I won't be reading the sequel.
The White Oak is now available in e-book format via Amazon and Barnes & Noble.
An e-galley was provided by the publisher via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.
Seventeen-year-old Ismae was rescued from a brutal arranged marriage three years earlier when she was taken to the convent of St. Mortain. Here she was trained to become a deadly assassin, able to wield weapons and poisons with dangerous precision. When it's believed that Anne of Brittany's older brother, Gavriel Duval, is betraying his sister and country to the French, Ismae is sent to become a member of his household in order to keep an eye on him. Having grown up in a country town and then a convent, Ismae must learn to navigate the intrigues and deceptions of court, all the while trying not to fall in love with the person she very well may have to kill.
This book was really and truly awesome. Honestly, that was my only thought the entire time I was reading it, and once I'd finished. I absolutely adored the look at this semi-fictional Brittany, with the insertion of the magic and lore of the gods and the beliefs of those that followed them. I found Ismae to be a really refreshing heroine with a wonderful voice; while physically strong and capable, she's far from perfect, and has to navigate not only her past but her uncertainty regarding her present and future. I loved watching her grow as she started to really question what she wanted to do with her life and the fact that the convent might not always be right, or even the best path for her. She was faced with a lot of truly difficult decisions, and I was rooting for her as she navigated them all.
And Duval! What a swoon-worthy hero! It was so refreshing to see a truly GOOD guy who cared so deeply for his family and only wanted what was best for his sister. I so appreciated that the romance between him and Ismae didn't just pop up instantaneously but was very slow-burning. I liked the fact that they became friends first, sharing an alliance that slowly grew into more. By the time the romance actually happened, it seemed like such a natural progression that I hardly blinked at it because it was just perfect for what was going on in the book at that time. I also loved how Duval was able to help Ismae let go of her past, how she naturally grew more trusting of him, and how he was able to help her realize that she wasn't just a weapon of the convent. He was perfect for her, and she for him, and I just really loved the entire progression of their relationship.
This book was full of such twists and turns that I was constantly guessing and wondering what was going to happen next. I was literally unable to put it down until it was finished, because I just wanted to know how everything was going to be brought together for the finale of the book. This was a really perfect read for me that I thoroughly enjoyed from beginning to end. I am really looking forward to the second book, and learning more of Sybella; I hope she's able to get a happy ending, too.
An e-galley was provided by the publisher via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.